update 1.1.042
-
@Victor-Vector When an individual node of a shape is selected, the other nodes of the shape also become visible by showing small (non selected) circles.
Currently, this should indicate which shape contains the node.In the earlier drawing, I see that the orange highlight is sometimes drawn before and in other times after the selected node. Is there some rule for this? I'd like to explore this idea a bit as a new feature.
-
@VectorStyler
Thank you for considering this idea. I will offer the disclaimer that this is by no means a fully thought out solution, just an initial concept for a way to offer more clarity in feedback to a user in a situation with complex node selection relationships.I made another mockup to help illustrate the issue and the potential solution:

Figure A shows two shapes, a rectangle and a circle that have been cut into separate pieces using Menu > Object > Shape > Cut Path with Intersections.
The result in Figure A has been pulled apart so one can understand the separate segments, but in the example, the shape would not be pulled apart, and it would look like Figure B. I have labelled key segments with numbers 1, 2, and 3.Figure B shows the intended selection as it currently works in VectorStyler. Of course the colors and shapes of the nodes are user choices. I have chosen a dull magenta for "selected" and various shapes to represent the smooth, cusp, and end nodes. These are not defaults and your choices will be different.
Selected are: the two top nodes of segment 1, the middle node of segment 2, and the top node of of segment 3. The representation becomes particularly confusing where segments 1, 2, and 3 meet. It is hard to determine what end point arrow is selected; is it segment 2 or segment 3?Figure C shows a mockup of what a selected node's segment highlight might look like. The color can be user configurable, of course. I have chosen orange to illustrate the idea here.
I feel like it is more clear what is being selected, and helps the user navigate such complexities with a decent amount of visual feedback, while hopefully not being too complex to implement.Figure C also shows the highlight color behaviour of the segments when multiple nodes are selected i.e.: segment 1, and when a middle node is selected, i.e.: segment 2.
I would add that this is not an original idea. I have used software where selection of individual nodes is illustrated like this for clarity, I think it was FontLab, if I am not mistaken..
I hope that clarifies the idea more. Again, just an early idea...
-
@Victor-Vector When the paths are a lighter color you can see that both the nodes of the path and the path itself are highlighted:

But when they are black like in your screenshot, indeed the highlight of the path — its spine — is not visible.
@VectorStyler Maybe use a (thicker?) light blue highlight for the spine of the path when selected, so it works for black and darker strokes?
-
@b77 said in update 1.1.042:
But when they are black like in your screenshot, indeed the highlight of the path — its spine — is not visible.
Wouldn't this be fixed by changing your layer color indicator? I worry that if we thicken those lines, it's going to be less useful and look less professional
-
@Boldline I don't insist on thicker, no.
-
@b77 lol I was just wondering if switching the layer color itself solved the problem for you. Out of curiosity, how thick would you want it to be?
-
@Boldline said in update 1.1.042:
Wouldn't this be fixed by changing your layer color indicator?
You're right, but…
Why not have the app override that color and always use something that has enough contrast no matter the color of the stroke?
-
@Boldline said in update 1.1.042:
@b77 Out of curiosity, how thick would you want it to be?
At least on Retina screens it seems to be 1 pixel thick. 2 px would be better, IMO.
-
@Boldline said in update 1.1.042:
Wouldn't this be fixed by changing your layer color indicator?
Actually, no. It's the same standard blue, no matter what the layer color is.
@VectorStyler Can this be changed somewhere?
-
@b77
Using the transform tool, the path indicator is blue but my selection box is green in correlation with the layer color indicator.

When I switch to the node editing tool i can see the color of my layer clearly against the black

-
@Boldline Got it, indeed it changes color in node editing mode.

-
@b77 said in update 1.1.042:
Why not have the app override that color and always use something that has enough contrast no matter the color of the stroke?
Same could be done for the node segment highlight color idea. If the highlight color was orange, for example, and the stroke color was also orange, the VS app could override that color with a contrasting one.
-
@b77 said in update 1.1.042:
Actually, no. It's the same standard blue, no matter what the layer color is.
@VectorStyler Can this be changed somewhere?Is this the path spine color? It is blue when hovering over the path, and turns to the layer color once selected.
-
@Victor-Vector said in update 1.1.042:
Same could be done for the node segment highlight color idea. If the highlight color was orange, for example, and the stroke color was also orange, the VS app could override that color with a contrasting one.
Yes, when in node editing mode (of which node selection is part of), if possible have a (low-key) color that always has enough contrast with the color of the stroke.
@VectorStyler Yes, the path spine color.